Great moments in theology:
2000 B.C.E— Rejecting polytheism, Abraham declares that there’s only one god, implying that everything is interconnected and therefore religion has something to do with morality.
1500 B.C.E— Moses conceives the notion of lawful progress and change, thanks to which the way things are is not the way things have to be.
500 B.C.E.— Buddha conceives the notion of observation and analysis as a prerequisite for action.
500 B.C.E.— Confucius establishes his Golden Rule of reciprocity, kindness, and sincerity as a tool for advancing human relations.
30 C.E.— Jesus promotes the value of love, compassion, and forgiveness in human relationships.
613 C.E.— Muhammad perceives that all the world’s great religions essentially deliver the same message.
1977 C.E.— In the film Providence, Alain Resnais portrays God as a sick and lonely creator who’s lost control of his creation.
2023 C.E.— At his bar mitzvah in Brooklyn, my grandson Roscoe Rubin-Rottenberg contemplates a Torah passage in which God smites two skeptics for the crime of nonbelief. Roscoe concludes (with the apparent, if unspoken, acquiescence of his rabbi): “God is an asshole.”
Eaten by worms?
In the three years since then, I’ve had many occasions to think about Roscoe’s conclusion— and not just because Roscoe has yet to be struck by lightning. Flip open your Torah, Bible, or Quran, and it’s astonishing how often God solves a problem by smiting somebody— and sometimes entire nations— especially on matters of religion. Is God really so insecure?
When the Israelites of the Hebrew scriptures are threatened by enemies, God’s customary m.o. is wipe out the entire rival population— the good people along with the bad— through plagues, natural disasters, fire, and direct execution. For instance:
· In Genesis, God sends a global flood to destroy all of humanity because of widespread wickedness, sparing only Noah and his family.
· Also in Genesis, God rains sulfur and fire down on the wicked cities Sodom and Gomorrah, destroying all the inhabitants.
· In Exodus, God sends ten plagues and kills the firstborn of Egypt to punish Pharaoh and the Egyptians for refusing to free the Israelites. Then God collapses the Red Sea back onto Pharaoh’s pursuing army, drowning the soldiers. In a democracy like ours, ordinary American voters might conceivably be held accountable for the sins of Donald Trump. But why make ordinary Egyptians pay for their Pharaoh’s offenses?
· In Leviticus, God consumes Aaron’s sons with fire from heaven because they offered unauthorized incense.
· In Numbers, the earth opens up and swallows Korah, Dathan, Abiram, and their followers for rebelling against Moses and Aaron, while fire consumes 250 others.
· In Samuel, God strikes Uzzah dead instantly when he reaches out to steady the Ark of the Covenant, because touching the Ark was forbidden. That’ll teach him to mind his own business!
· In Acts, one of God’s angels smites King Herod Agrippa, who is eaten by worms and dies because he accepts worship as a god instead of giving glory to God.
Today, such a mass murderer would be hauled before the International Criminal Court for genocide. Or committed to a home for the criminally insane.
Lenny Bruce’s dyke joke
Now consider God’s advice about child-rearing. Were it up to me, I would give a disobedient kid a time out, or maybe withhold dessert at dinner time until he or she shaped up. But according to Deuteronomy, if a son was stubbornly rebellious, a glutton, a drunkard, and completely refused to listen to his mother and father, the parents were to bring him before the city elders. If found guilty of adult degeneracy and total contempt for authority, the legal punishment was— what else?— death by stoning in order to “purge the evil” from the community.
Now, here’s my question: Is God really so lacking in imagination? Has no one informed God of alternatives to the death penalty and/or torture, like imprisonment, or a fine, or community service? Why is rehabilitation or therapy utterly absent from God’s playbook? And that being the case, why are so many people (aside, apparently, from my grandson Roscoe) so preoccupied with proclaiming the greatness and the glory of God?
The answer may be found in Lenny Bruce’s old gag about why people tell fag jokes but no one tells dyke jokes: “Because dykes will beat the shit out of you.” Or the joke that asks: What do you call a demented seven-foot-tall vagrant carrying a spear? Answer: “Sir.”
As for Jesus…
The New Testament isn’t much wiser when it comes to dealing with adversity. In Luke, Jesus suggests, “But those enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them— bring them here and kill them in front of me.” (The customary apologia is that Jesus was speaking in the form of a parable. But the nobleman of his parable is clearly meant to represent Jesus himself, for the nobleman then heads to Jerusalem to proclaim his kingdom.)
Of course, God didn’t write any of these stories. We know they’re all the product of fallible human scribes, doing their limited best with the limited knowledge of their times. As such, they’re a reflection not on God but on authors who hadn’t yet been introduced to, say, Spinoza or John Stuart Mill or Thomas Jefferson or Sigmund Freud or Albert Einstein.
The real reason we should praise God, according to my Philadelphia rabbi emeritus, Avi Winokur, is that we spend so much time kvetching that we need something we can applaud for a change. Even if God is a figment of our imagination. Even if God is an asshole. That’s why I aarrgh! Help! My right hand is withering and the keyboard is totally gobbledygook.etaion shrdlu sjhrlu shrdu.
(Social media processor’s note: The author’s file ends here.)


If God speaks through Trump - as it is claimed by the Evangelicals - why can't he speak through Rottenberg?
It is more accurate, perhaps, to simply see God as a reflection of both the best and worst of we humans.